Dan: On this episode we discuss The Bye Bye Man.
Stuart: The bizarre-but-true story of newshound Edward R. Murrow!
Dan: What?
Stuart: Wasn't that his signoff? "Bye bye!"
Elliott: (unamused) No.

Official Show NotesEdit

"Shocktober concludes with the playfully titled The Bye Bye Man, starring the titular Bye Bye Man and some boring people. Meanwhile, Elliott channels Freddy Krueger to give the Bye Bye Man some advice, Stu explains Dan doesn't have to pick up floor food, and Dan has some questions about fish blow jobs."

Movie SummaryEdit



  • "The Happy Fisherman" shower curtain @12:45, 20:20, 36:30, 1:09:00, 1:09:55

Final JudgmentsEdit

  • Totally Snorifying (Stuart) @53:20
  • Totally Snorifying (Elliott) @53:30
  • Totally Snorifying (Dan) @53:50

Episode HighlightsEdit


The Freddy & Jason tangent

The Freddy & Jason tangent

Movie PitchesEdit

The Bye Bye Man 2: The Bad News Buddy
The Bye Bye Man 2: The Goodbye Kid
Stuart's planned directorial debut.


  • ­Much like Huey Lewis, you want a new Jug...head.
         —Elliott @35:26
  • ­There's something sweet about that. I like that all these movie monsters have found love.
         —Elliott @41:15
  • ­There's nothing in the rulebook that says a dog can't kill people with hallucinations.
         —Elliott @45:45
  • ­Fuck you, movie.
         —Dan @49:22
  • ­If only Hitler hadn't told all those Jews about the Bye Bye Man, he wouldn't have had to do all that.
         —Elliott @51:10
  • ­Remember the time when we were recording and Stuart got up, left [to go] to the bathroom, and changed into a tiny bathing suit?
         —Elliott @1:04:10
  • ­This is making me very uncomfortable…very uncomfortable.
         —Dan @1:09:40


Listener MailEdit

Mailbag SongEdit



"What are your favorite French films?" from Bartholomew Lastnamewithheld @1:10:00
"Mail Title" from Mallory Lastnamewithheld @Time
"Mail Title" from Stubert McLastnamewithheld @1:17:15


  • Applecart (2017) by Brad Baruh (Stuart) @1:21:00
  • Gerald's Game (2017) by Mike Flanagan starring Carla Gugino (Dan) @1:23:22
  • Happy Death Day (2017) by Christopher Landon (Dan) @1:25:08
  • Queen of Earth (2015) by Alex Ross Perry (Elliott) @1:25:58
  • Christine (2016) by Antonio Campos (Elliott) @1:26:31


Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.